How we score providers
Ordinal, evidence-typed and transparent. Every level has a written definition, a weight, a source URL and a capture date. Missing information is shown as "not documented" and excluded from the band; it never counts as zero. The map combines documented criteria into delivery scope and verifiable rigor.
Criteria and weights
Price transparency · weight 20%
Do you know what you will pay before talking to sales?
- Site explicitly says contact for quote
- Publishes only a starting price, without what it includes
- Publishes a range or named packages with partial inclusions
- Publishes fixed package prices with inclusions and exclusions listed
- Level 3 plus online checkout or a public standard contract, or price confirmed by a third party
Scope of deliverables · weight 20%
What comes out finished: FDD, agreement, manual, financial model, registrations?
- Strategy only; no documents delivered
- One core document (FDD only, or manual only)
- FDD plus franchise agreement (the legal minimum to sell)
- Level 2 plus operations manual plus at least one of financial model, state registration, training, or sales/marketing
- Level 3 plus trademark and state registrations, itemized deliverables and a public sample or verified case
Verifiable legal competence · weight 20%
Is the FDD signed by a licensed attorney with registration-state and Item 19 experience?
- Documents generated without attorney review, or unnamed in-house lawyer
- Says it works with attorneys, without naming a firm or person
- Names a partner attorney or firm, or explicitly recommends review by the client's franchise attorney
- Named attorney, licensed (state or bar number), franchise-law practice page, registration states mentioned
- Level 3 plus third-party recognition in franchise law, or substantive Item 19 and renewal publications with filings declared
Franchise experience and focus · weight 15%
How long, how many systems, and is franchising the main practice?
- Franchising is one of several areas; under 2 years; no cases
- Franchising as declared focus, under 5 years, no named cases
- 5 or more years, or 10 or more named clients on the site
- 10 or more years and a named portfolio of 25 or more systems, or systems launched declared with a date
- Level 3 confirmed by a third party (public FDDs naming the firm, supplier rankings, verified reviews, press)
Post-launch support and annual compliance · weight 10%
Is there a named annual FDD update, state renewals, or continuing counsel, and at what price?
- Site says delivery is one-time, no updates
- Mentions generic ongoing support
- Annual FDD update or state renewals offered as a named service
- Level 2 with a published price or recurring plan and the compliance calendar explained
- Level 3 plus a compliance portal, continuing counsel with SLA, or third-party review mentioning renewals
Documented timeline · weight 10%
How fast is delivery, and is it written down?
- Site says it depends; no commitment
- Over 26 weeks
- 13 to 26 weeks
- 2 to 12 weeks
- 1 week or less, written on a product page or terms
Third-party reputation · weight 5%
Rankings, directories, verified reviews, complaints.
- Unanswered BBB complaints, regulatory action, or relevant public litigation
- Testimonials on the provider's own site only
- Verified reviews on an independent platform (10 or more at 4.0 or higher) or confirmed IFA membership
- Level 2 plus an industry ranking or trade-press citation
- Legal or consulting band ranking (Chambers, Legal 500, Best Lawyers) or 50 or more verified reviews at 4.5 or higher
Evidence rules
- P (provider site) evidence supports levels 0 to 3. Level 4 requires T (third party) or R (regulatory) evidence.
- Level 0 is only given with explicit negative evidence, such as "contact for quote" or "no attorney review".
- Evidence older than 12 months is marked "to confirm"; older than 18 months reverts to not documented.
Bands
Band = weighted mean of the scored criteria only. A provider needs at least 5 of 7 criteria documented to receive a band; otherwise it is "Not classified". Band A additionally requires two T or R sources, otherwise it is capped at B.
- A · Documented leader — score of 3.25 or higher
- B · Solid — score of 2.5 or higher
- C · Basic — score of 1.5 or higher
- D · Early or thinly documented — score of 0 or higher
See the scorecard for all providers.
Corrections
Use the source on each provider profile to check a score or listing. To suggest a correction, email hello@howfranchise.com with the listing and supporting source.
Change log
- 2026-11-18 — Rubric v1 adopted; replaces the earlier radar and price-by-speed quadrants.